Lecture 13
Child
Psychopathology and Cognitive Disorders
Dale L. Johnson
Child Disorders
In
this course we barely touch on the abnormal psychology of children. There is a
course at UH that deals exclusively with this topic. The textbook takes up
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder, Learning Disorders, Autistic Disorder
and Mental Retardation and touches on a few other disorders. It does not deal
with obsessive-compulsive disorder, depression, schizophrenia or anxiety, to
name but a few other disorders that affect children.
Classification
Issues
On
of the major problems in this field has been the question of how best to
classify child disorders. The practice that has been adopted by the American
Psychiatric Association is to use the same system thatis used for adults and to
add a section on developmental disorders. There are problems with this
approach. For example, in order to make a diagnosis of depression the examiner
must talk with the person and ask that person to report on her or his affective
experience. Observation alone is insufficient. This calls for reflecting on
one's experience, that is mentally reviewing one's history, and comparing one's
present affective state with what recalls about the state from the past. It
also calls for making comparisons with the experience of other people. Very
young children cannot do this, but adolescents can. This ability to reflect on
one's experience is a developmental process takes place over the years. The
DSM-IV does not handle this problem well.
There
is another problem. Many educators and others are reluctant to assign a
diagnostic label to a child. They know that this label will make its way into
school or other records and the child may be stigmatized by this action. They
usually just avoid the issue and if the child is in need of special attention
is simply assigned to a special education class. This avoidance of
classification results in uncertainty about the prevalence of child disorders.
Some
of problems that children have are almost entirely developmental problems; that
is, they appear in childhood and disappear as the child matures into adulthood.
An excellent example of this is enuresis, or bed wetting. All infants wet the
bed at night and almost no adults do. In part it is a social issue because it
is expected by parents, and children, that they will have dry nights when they
reach a certain age. What that age is varies from family to family, but there
is some agreement that it should occur by age 5. The wetting rates (wet at
least once per week) change as follows: age 3, 20%, age 4, 15%, age 5, 12%, age
6, 10% and age 7, 8%, age 14, 2%. Thus, most children are dry at night by age
3, but a few continue to have a problem. Boys are twice as likely as girls to
be enuretic.
For
many years enuresis was defined as a neurotic problem and was seen as an
expression of repressed hostility toward the mother. Psychotherapy of the
dynamic variety was prescribed. There have been many studies of its
effectiveness and they in agreement that the method is not at all effective. In
1938 Hobart Mowrer, then a graduate student at Yale, defined the disorder as
developmental and designed a new form of treatment: the bell and pad procedure.
In this the parent is given a one-hour training session and is instructed to
put the child to bed without pajamas. The bed has a sheet on top of a metal
screen, then another sheet and another metal screen. Finally, there is another
sheet and a waterproof pad. The two metal screens are connected to a bell. When
the child urinates during sleep a circuit is completed between the two metal
screens and the bell rings waking the child and the parent. The sheets are
changed, the bell is reset and the child is put back to bed. The procedue is a
clear instance of classical (associative or Pavlovian) conditioning. Bladder
tension is the conditioned stimulus, the bell is the unconditioned stimulus and
rhe response is waking up. There have been many studies of the effectiveness of
this procedure. It is effective in producing dry nights for more than 80% of
children. Thus, it is one of the most effective procedures ever developed by
psychologists. It was not widely used until the 1970s because pscyhodynamic
theorists insisted that when one symptom (bedwetting) was removed another
symptom would take its place. Several studies have proved this wrong. Dry-night
children tend to do better in all ways. Incidently, the apparatus for this
procedure is available at a low cost at Sears (or it was when I last checked).
Today, an alternatives to the bell-and-pad exists. It is the drug imipramine.
Apparently, the drug affects the sleep pattern and the child sleeps less
soundly and is more easily aware of bladder tension. It is effective, but not
as effective as the bell and pad.
There
is another problem about describing an abnormal psychology of children.
Children are not fully autonomous beings. They tend much more than adults to be
a part of the social context in which they live. For most children the
important context is the child's family. Picasso's "The tragedy"
wonderfully depicts this situation. In this Blue Period painting we see a
woman, a man and a child who is about 10 years old. The scene is on a seashore.
The woman and man have arms crossed and they are both looking down and away
from each other. They stand near, but apart. The child also looks down, but his
right hand is on the man's thigh. In this painting we see grief and sorrow, and
we see the child's sharing of his sorrow, admittedly incompletely understood,
with the adults. His hand on the man's thigh shows a connection with the
adults. His own world is complete only when it is in connection with his
family. Picasso, in a single painting, has expressed a fact that generations of
psychologists have finally arrived at. To know the child one must know his/her
context. There are many implications of this for the treatment of child
psychological disorders. The main one is that one does not treat the child
alone; one treats the child in and through the family. A flurry of research in
the early 1970s made that clear. I would never treat a child individually in
play therapy today, although I did in the past. The results are disappointing.
I would treat the child with the family. One works not only to change the
child, the way she or he thinks and feels, but one changes the social context
of the child to be supportive of child well-being.
Disorders
of Undercontrolled Behavior
Some
researchers have divided the main types of child behavior problems into two
types: those of undercontrolled behaviors and those that are overcontrolled.
This leaves out much, but it is a starting point.
Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder
(ADHD)
Chief
among the undercontrolled disorders is ADHD. The disorder is common, but the
prevalence is difficult to know, in part because there has never been a
national epidemiological study of child behavior problems in the United States.
There have been in the Netherlands, Canada and several other countries, but not
in the USA. Another problem is that there has been difficulty in arriving at an
acceptable definition of ADHD. From the studies that we do have it appears that
the prevalence is about 120-500/10,000 children; that is, 1.2% to 5% of
children. There is a gender difference: boys are more likely to have the
disorder than girls by a ratio of about
2-3 to 1. The rates are boys 8.9% and girls 3.3%.
An
early view of the disorder was that it was a problem of hyperactivity, but
research carried out by Virginia Douglas in Canada showed that the disorder is
basically one of an attention deficit. These children do not focus well on
tasks at hand and because they do not focus well they skip from one thing to
another and seem over-active.
There
have been many theories of the cause or etiology of the disorder. These have
included minimal brain injury, diet, lead, genetic, food addititives,
florescent lighting, and, of course, family environment.
Genetics
Twin
studies have offered some evidence that genetics may be involved. In one twin
study the monozygotic concordance was 51% compared with the dizygotic rate of
33%. As you are aware, this is only suggestive of a genetic disorder. In
addition there is evidence that a defective gene found in families of people
with ADHD codes for a thyroid hormone receptor that causes generalized resistance
to thyroid hormone.
Brain
Involvement
Researchers
at the National Institute for Mental Health using PET scans found children with
ADHD showed less brain activity than normal children in the premotor cortex and
the superior prefrontal cortex. The neurotransmitter dopamine plays a large
role in the functioning of the prefrontal cortex.
Family
Environment
As
to family environment, I have seen many children with their parents in our
clinic. A small number of them appear to have no control over their children,
or even worse, they send their children such a mixture of messages that the
child cannot know what is expected. In these cases parental management of the
child appears involved in the disorder although it may not be the only element.
Other
There
have been many fads in this area. Research has discounted claims that food
additives (don't eat Fritos or drink Kool Aid) or refined sugar (Twinkies), or
florescent lighting in schools are involved.
Minimal
brain injury is associated with attention problems. There is little doubt today
that there is brain involvement. Almost certainly there is some problem in the
frontal-limbic and pefrontal cortices as shown by PET scans.
Fetal
alcohol syndrome is definitely involved in the cause of some ADHD as is maternal
smoking during pregnancy.
Ingestion
of lead also results in ADHD-like conditions.
Treatment
Treatment
should follow assessment. For details on the kind of assessment that is
necessary see Barkley, R. A. (1990). Attention
deficit hyperactivity disorder: a handbook for diagnosis and treatment. New
York: Guilford. Assessment includes an interview with the child and parents,
behavior rating scales completed by parents and teachers, and sometime
psychological testing. One test used often is a computerized measure of
attentional abilities. This assessment should lead to a correct diagnosis. It
is unfortunate that too many children are given the diagnosis and are treated
with stimulant medication, but do not actually have ADHD; they are just
misbehaving.
There
are also many types of attention deficit disorder. The most common type is that
which includes hyperactivity, but there is another that includes only a kind of
spaciness. The child does not pay attention. As one nine year old girl told me,
"I cannot play soccer because the other girls don't want me. They say I
don't pay atention to the ball. It's true. My mind wanders." It is not
good for a nine-year-old to be rejected by her peers playing soccer because she
does not pay attention. She did not pay attention to much of anything else
either, but was helped a great deal by Ritalin and some attention training at
the UH Clinic.
The
only treatment that has been shown to have a positive effect on attention
deficit is the use of stimulant medications such as amphetamine,
methylphenidate and pemoline. Ritalin,
the trade name for methylphenidate, is the most widely used medication. A new
drug is rising fast in use. Concerta offers 12-hour effectiveness thus, if
taken in the morning, eliminates the noon medication. Stimulants probably work
by raising serotonin levels to counter the high dopamine levels and calm the
child (Caron, 1999, Science, 283, 397).
Stimulants
are not without side effects. There may be weight loss, mild insomnia, reduced
appetite and even growth retardation. However, claims that this early
(prescribed) drug intake leads to drug abuse are wrong. In fact, the opposite
occurs. Children with ADHD on medication are less likely to abuse drugs later
than children with ADHD who are not on the medication (Pediatrics, 1999,
Aug. 2).
Stimulant
medications are used a great deal in America today. Many people, and I am among
them, believe they are the easy way out and are over-used. They are given to
children who do not have ADHD and they are given without ancillary psychosocial
treatments. They should only be given after a careful psychological examination
by a competent examiner. Pediatricians should not prescribe the drugs without
this examination.
UH
clinical psychology graduate, Teodoro Ayllon, demonstrated years ago that while
stimulants help children focus better and control their impulsivity they do not
help with school performance or social skills. For these psychosocial methods
are necessary. One of my favorite ADHD children was treated with Ritalin and
family-oriented behavioral treatment when he was four just after being kicked
out of his third day care center for bad behavior. The family followed through
with treatment and thought it was quite effective. Today this boy is grown and
is a financial consultant with several offices in the Houston area.
Current
research on self-control will probably lead to improved treatments.
Prognosis
The
treatments are usually only partly effective and a large numberof children grow
to become adults who still have the condition. Although they are at risk for
substance abuse and accidental death this is not the fate for all ADHD people.
A son of friends of mine had ADHD and he was a poor student. His situation was
made worse by the fact that his three siblings were all brilliant honors
students. After doing badly in a succession of colleges he went into
construction work. Today he owns a framing company and his wife handles all of
the business side of it. He told me he always asks prospective employees if they
have ever had ADHD. If they have he hires them. He said, "They'll drive
nails all day without a break." In another example, Michael Zane, founder
of the Kryptonite bicycle lock, has ADHD and he attributes his success to the
disorder: "I have always been able to do more and think faster and in more
directions at once than most people." (New York Times, 10/31/00)
Websites
Amer.
Acad. of Pediatrics
www.aap.org/policy/ac0002.pdf
Amer.
Psychol. Assn.
www.apa.org/releases/adhteens.html
UCLA
School
smhp.psych.ucla.edu/pdfdocs/Atention.pdf
Disorders
of Overcontrolled Behavior
Fears
Children
have fears. Any parent knows that. Why do they fear, and what do they fear?
There have been two major points of view. One is the nativist position which
holds that certain fears are built in, a part of being a young human, and part
of the path of evolution that provides self-protection. They cite evidence of
the fear of depths such as the fear of falling. This is tested using a visual
cliff at 6 months of age. There is no real cliff; it is only apparent,but young
children who have never seen a cliff show fear of falling. In the development
of emotions, positive emotions develop before negative. Signs of happiness appear
very early. For the infant there is a perceived opening of the world, the world
is right for them and they are happy. In fear there is a perceived threat to
safety.
The
other side has been taken by the empiricist position and they say fear is a
product of conditioning. The classical study of this is of Little Albert who
was conditioned to fear a pet rat by making a loud noise each time Albert
approached the rat. Empiricists believe learn to fear certain objects and
places because of painful experiences with them.
Clearly,
both points of view are necessary to account for all cases of fears.
Perhaps
the main fear held by children is that of loss of parents. This is the primary
threat to safety.
Phobia
Fears
are also phobias. One of the major ones of these is school phobia, also called
school refusal. In this the child, usually quite young, refuses to go to
school. If pressed he/she makes an enormous fuss and parents typically give in,
"Just this once." Except it happens again the next day. I recently worked
with a family who had a 6 year old boy who refused to go to school. Parents
talked with the teacher and learned that nothing had happened and that the boy
was an exceptionally good student. He liked to stay home with his mother. After
checking out several possible reasons for his refusal and finding nothing of
importance I had the parents tell the teacher that they would bring the boy to
school and would then drive away. He would fuss, but they were not coming back
until the usual post-school pick-up time. They did that and he fussed mightily
for about 30 minutes. They did the same the next day and he fussed to 10
minutes. On the third day his heart was not in it and only fussed for a few
minutes. On the fourth day he accepted school happily. There have been no
relapses. In this we used exposure to the feared object, the school, and knew
that by his living through his fear he would master it. It worked. Reearch has
shown that it almost always works. It is a form of behavior therapy called
exposure. Note, however, that in my example above there were no apparent
adverse circumstances. If the parental marriage is breaking up and the child
has fears about this it may require a different course of treatment. If the
child is the object of bullying on the school ground, the bullying has to be
managed. Learning about complicating circumstances calls for a careful
assessment of the situation.
Treatment
The
treatments for child anxiety disorders including phobias are similar to those
for adults, except the parents are always included in the treatment plan. The
methods include
Desensitization
See textbook.
Modelling
In dog phobia, for example, if a
parent shows fear of dogs it is common for the the child also to show fear.
Treatment consists of showing the child that the dog is not dangerous and
actually fun to play with. Fear disappears rapidly.
Skill
development
Many phobias develop out of specific
fears, such as the fear of water. Part of the treatment for this is to develop
swimming skills. I recall when my wife was teaching swimming one of her
students was a 6 foot 4 inch 20-year old man who has terribly afraid of water
and wanted to overcome the fear. He chose to learn to swim from this 5 foot 1
inch instructor. He did well, was swimming up and down the pool and diving off
the high board in a few days. It was a matter of getting into the water at the
shallow end and working gradually, and with a series of successes, moving on to
deep water.
Depression
As
mentioned above the identification of depression in young children is
difficult. I was once asked to help the staff at a Head Start center with a
4-year-old who was unusually violent. He would hit, kick and stratch other
children and throw toys at the teachers. He was uncontrollable. After an
observation period when it became clear that he was very angry I had one
assistant teacher place herself within a step or two of him at all times. If he
seemed ready to hit she was to engulf him with her arms and simply hold him for
30 seconds. His aggressive behavior stopped and he began spending all of his
time under tables. The head teacher made a home visit and learned several
things: the father and mother had had a noisy argument and the father had left
home. Second, a little later, there was a fire in the family apartment and the
baby sister died in the flames. The mother had stepped out for a few minutes.
The little boy blamed himself for not saving the baby. We had the boy act out
the fire with fire engines, etc., while the head teacher commented on what he was
doing. She did not interpret. He got better. Then daddy came home and he got
well. In this case with a very young child environmental manipulations were
used with success. Note that the boy did not say that he was depressed; it is
doubtful that he had any awareness of the concept. His world was wrong and he
was unhappy with it and with himself. We inferred his depression from the
circumstances that surrounded him and from his behavior that indicated he was
not happy with the way things were going.
Older
children and adolescents respond well to cognitive behavior therapy. There is
much discussion now about the use of medication and clinical trials are
underway. If it is found to be effective I would hope that it is used very
carefully because of the unknown side effects, and because psychological
methods work so well.
Serious Emotional Disorder
Some children not only have severe
disorders, but they tend to have symptoms of many disorders. They do not do
well in school, they have no friends, and their parents do not know what to do.
The causes of these disorders are many and effective treatments are few.
Specifically this group includes children with childhood schizophrenia, some
bipolar disorder, some obsessive compulsive disorder, and many with no easily
named disorder.
Autism
The textbook has a good
coverage of this topic. One thing: keep in mind that although there are many
treatments for autism and they vary in popularity there is only one
treatment that has had its
effectiveness demonstrated through controlled clinical trials. That is the
behavioral treatment developed by Ivar Lovaas at UCLA. One of the few places in
the USA where this program is being applied is at the University of Houston by
its Psychology Clinic. Dr. Gerald Harris directs the program. UH undergraduates
do much of the actual treatment. Medical treatments have not been very
effective. Anti-psychotic drugs have been used and they do help to control some
symptoms, and antidepressant drugs such as Prozac suppress repetitive movements,
but these drugs are no substitute for behavioral methods.
There has been much
concern recently about an apparent increase in the incidence of autism. Parents
of children with autism have taken up the idea that this increase is
caused by vaccination that are given to
all young children and some of the measles vaccinations have small amounts of
mercury. The belief is that that the mercury causes autism. There are several
interesting research questions in this line of reasoning. First, is it true
that the incidence of autism is increasing? Unfortunately the United States
Center for Disease Control cannot answer that question because the USA does not
collect incidence data on developmental or psychiatric disorders. They record
the incidence of measles, flu, etc., but not psychiatric disorders. Therefore,
we look to countries that do record incidence, such as those in Scandinavia. A
study in Finland showed an increase, but the authors attributed the increase,
at least in part, to changes in ways of classifying the disorder and
identifying it. There may be no real change, just that more cases are
identified. A similar study in Israel found no increase above the expected
1:10,000 rate. Nevertheless, epidemiologists in California believe there is an
increase, but do not know why.
What about the
vaccination question? First, vaccinations are administered after the child is
born, at about 18 months, and all
evidence of the cause of autism is that it begins prenatally and symptoms are
first noticed at about 18 months. Second, the amount of mercury is too low to
have any effects on brains of animals or humans. Third, in Denmark and the
United Kingdom, the prevalence of autism was examined before the introduction
of the measles vaccine and after and no changes in prevalence were observed.
Measles vaccinations do not cause autism and parents should make sure their
children are vaccinated. There is an increase of measles in the USA, because
parents have neglected or refused to have vaccinations.
I is increasingly clear
from twin and family studiesthat autism is to a large extent a genetic
disorder. Now it has been found that
autistic children have a shortened form of the serontonin transporter gene.
There is also evidence that the WNT2 gene, located on chromosome 7, is implicated.
Websites
National Academy of
Sciences:
www.nap.edu/books/0309072697/html
Pediatrics
www.pediatrics.org/cgi/content/full/105/5/e65
Amer. Acad.
Pediatrics
www.pediatrics.org/content/full/107/5/e85
Natl. Instit. Mental
Health
www.athealth.com/consumer/disorders/autism.html
*************************************
I can do
anything now at age 90
that I could
do when I was 18,
which only
shows how pathetic
I was at 18.
Anon.
Aging and Cognitive Disorders
The prportion of elderly people in
America, and in much of the world, in relation to the rest of the population
has grown rapidly. In 1900 only 4% of population were over 65 years of age. By
1987 this proportion had grown to 12% and it is predicted that by 2040 the
percent will be in the 21-25% range. This increase in proportion of the
population has important implications for the nation in terms of the workforce,
but it also has public health implications.
Age, cohort and time of
measurement effects
There are cohort effects to be
considerd, that is effects related to the time a group of people are born and
experience together certain social and environmental issues. Thus Americans
those born in the 1950s were marked forever by the Viet Nam war experience. My
generation can never forget their experience of both the Great Depression and
WWII.
There are typically two kinds of
research when looking at groups of people. First, there are cross-sectional
studies. These are more common. In these one selects groups of people for
research by age categories. Such studies typically have shown declines in
intellectual functioning with aging. However much of this effect seems to be a
matter of where the researchers found subjects; e.g., nursing homes where those
with greatest disabilities are found.
Longitudinal studies follow the same
individuals over time. These studies have found much less decline, and what did
appear was associated with illness. The best examples of these two types of
research have been in the study of intelligence. Cross-sectional studies
consistenly found that as people aged they lost IQ points. Getting dumber was
regarded as inevitable. Then, longitudinal research came along and the same
people were followed from adolescence into their 90s. What the researchers
found is that people did not get dumber and verbal abilities especially held up
well. This is, of course, unless they developed a dementing illness such as
Alzheimers.
Diagnosing psychopathology in later
life
The DSM-IV is used in the the same
way as with younger people. The range of problems is about the same, but some
new disorders appear.
Old Age and Brain Disorders
The main new disorder is dementia,
or literally, a loss of mind. It used to be called senility, but that term was
too broad and vague to have much meaning and it has been replaced by several
more specific names for disorders. As for dementia as a broad category it is
found in approximately 30% of people over 80. Cerebrovascular accidents,
or strokes, are a major cause of
dementia.
Dementia of the Alzheimer’s Type
Alzheimer’s (1860)(AZ) disease is
involved in half of cases of dementia in the elderly. The diagnosis is made
only my microscopic analysis of brain tissue in autopsy. To make a diagnosis
while the person lives a process of exclusion is used to rule out other causes
of psychological changes. Early diagnosis is based on psychological testing to
detect memory problems, failure to integrate new information and failure to
learn new associations. New brain imaging methods may make early diagnosis
possible. For example, new PET scans show an excessive production of the
neurotransmitter dopamine (Science, 1993, 259, p. 898).
Alzheimers can occur in a person's
early 40s and is then called presenile dementia.
It is more common in poorly educated
people, but highly educated people are not immune. One of the University of
Houston Psychology professors after retirement developed Alzheimers. He had
been called, "Mr. Psychology," because he had contributed so much to
the field. His textbook was read by legions of undergraduate students all over
the nation.He was brilliant, witty and a kind man. He lost his memory
completely before he died.
There was, however, the famous study
of nuns living together in same environment for many years. Now in their 80s,
one third of them had developed AZ. Researchers looked at essays that had been
written by the women when they were young. Those who did not get AZ wrote
autobiographies that were more complex and had more ideas.
AZ is more common among women. It is
less likely among Japanese, Nigerians, Native Americans and the Amish. For
example, the more Cherokee one is, the less likely it is that one will develop
Alzheimers. AZ is age-related. The older one becomes the more likely it is the
AZ will develop. At age 90 the chances are 50-50.
It is a genetic disease. Chromosomes
that may be involved are located on chromosomes 21, 19, 14, 12, 1, 10. In a few days there may be more, or
less. Chromosome 14 is involved in a large number of early cases.
The disease is caused by a buildup
of amyloid protein which develops plaques in the brain. There are also
neurofibrillary tangles composed of tau protein. There is a massive loss of
brain cells.
AZ is related to Down syndrome. Both
involve C-21.
Treatment
There is little effective treatment.
However, the disease process can be slowed with vitamin E (2,000 I.U. daily or
selegiline (Eldepryl- 10 mg. daily). These do not help cognitive function, but
have a positive effect on ativities of daily living and so tend to delay
nursing home placement. There is a keen
interest in prevention with most emphasis placed on the use of antioxidants
such as vitamin E or C. The herbal, gingko biloba, may be of some value in delaying
deterioration of memory.
Caretakers of people with Alzheimers
have a great burden. Because the typical time after diagnosis until death is 8
years and part of this requires nursing home care the financial burden is
great. It is also difficult to see a loved one disappear as a person before
ones eyes. The biorgrapher of former president Ronald Reagan said, "for
the last 6 months he hasn't recognized me, and for the last 3 months I haven't
recognized him."
Several acetylcholinesterase
inhibitors are used in the early and middle stages to delay progression of the
disease.
As many patients develop severe
behavioral problems their management becomes a challenge. Antidepressant and
anti-anxiety medications are used with some effectiveness. In extreme case
anti-psychotic medications are used.
Websites
American Family Physician: www.aafp.org/afp/20020601/2263.html
www.aafp.org/afp/20020615/2525.html
Alzheimer's Association www.alz.org/famcare/overview.asp
National Institute of Aging www.nia.nih.gov/exercise/toc.htm
www.nia.nih.gov/heal/pubs/clinicians-handbook
Alzheimer's
(for Renee Mauger)
By
C. K. Williams
She answers
the bothersome telephone, takes the message, forgets
the message, forgets who called.
One of their
daughters, her husband guesses; the one with the
dogs, the babies, the boy Jed?
Yes, perhaps,
but how tell which, how tell anything when all the nametags have been lost or
switched,
when all the
lonely flowers of sense and memory bloom and die now in adjacent bites of time?
Sometimes her
own face will suddenly appear with terrifying inappropriateness before her in a
mirror.
She knows
that if she's patient its gaze will break, demurely, like a well-taught
child's,
it will turn
from her as though it were emarrassed by the secrets of this awful
hide-and-seek.
If she
forgets, though, and glances back again, it will still be in there, furtively
watching, crying.
Atlantic
Monthly, April, 1987.
Vascular Dementia
Stroke is the third leading cause of
death. Many people survive strokes, but lose some cognitive functioning with
each stroke. This disease affects 4.7% of men and 3.8% of women. Many cases
diagnosed as Alzheimer's are later discovered on autopsy to be forms of
vascular dementia
Dementia Due to Other General Medical
Conditions
There are many other potential
causes of dementia. Today, the most common of these is AIDs. Another obvious
source of dementia is head trauma caused by accidents where these is brain
damage. People of any age may be involved.
Parkinson’s Disease
This is a brain disorder involving the degeneration of dopaminergic neurons
within the substantia nigra . The prevalence is about 1/1000 worldwide. It is
the second most common degerative disorder after Alzheimers. It affects approximately
1% of the population over age 50. Among the symptoms are stooped posture, slow
movements, jerkiness in walking and a soft monotone voice. A reduction in
dopamine is involved. Some people develop dementia.
Some of you may remember the movie, Awakenings,
with Robin Williams. It was about a particular form of Parkinson's disease that
also involved exposure to the influenza epidemic of 1918.
Research has identified chromosome 4
as being involved, but is not a major factor. The susceptibility is largely
unknown although it is clear that environomental factors play a role. One
curious finding is that smoking reduces the risk of devleoping parkinson's
disease. Possible environmental causes include exposure to chemicals such as
pesticides and herbicides and diet. A drug--synthetic heroin--can cause PD-like
symptoms, but the actual environmental causes are not known.
Treatment. As PD is caused by the
death of cells in the substantia nigra which produces dopamine adding dopamine
as levodopa was believed to help. However, while it did produce miracle cures
in the short-run it didn’t work over time.
There is aslo a surgical procedure:
removal of the subthalamic nucleus. This procedure procuces remarkable results
in some patients.
Huntington’s Disease
Motor moverments are choreoformic;
that is, it seems as though the person is dancing. People develop signs of the
disease in their 30s and live another 20 years, although apparently people now
live into their 60s. Most people with the disease eventually develop dementia.
Many become psychotic.
Huntington's is a genetic dominant
disease. The genetic cause is the only cause and only one gene is involved.
Research instigated by Nancy Wexler whose family was involved with the disease
has shown that the gene is located on chromosome 4. As 50% of people at risk
for the disease, that is, who have a parent with the disease, will develop the
disease prevention is possible. People at risk should not have children.
However to say this is one thing, to convince people with the gene that they
should not have children is another. Martindale (1987, British Journal of
Psychiatry, 150, 319-323) found that professionals and people at risk
showed considerable denial. By not reproducing the disease could be eliminated.
As affected people do reproduce the disease continues. Fewer people who know
they have the gene now have children.
A famous sufferer was Woody Guthrie.
Pick’s Disease
This is a rare disease. It is a
cortical dementia similar to Alzheimers. It begins in the person's 40s and 50s.
Creutzfeld-Jacobs
This disease is rare, but as you
know from reading the papers, it may be caused by mad cow disease and has
spread rapidly in Europe. Don’t eat raw hamburger and avoid elk meat.
Good News
There is considerable evidence that
people who have a positive outlook on life live longer. Pessimists die younger.
Stay on an even emotional keel and live longer. These findings are based on
psychological tests administered to young people and then, years later, death
rates are examined. Older people who have a negative view of aging experience
more events as stressful. As you know, people who are optimistic and see
problems as a challenge, not as a source of debilitating stress, are healthier
in general, and are so throughout their lives. If you can't be happy, be
cantankerous; these argumentative,difficult people also live longer.