Today, invention at the wrong time. The
University of Houston's College of Engineering presents this series about the
machines that make our civilization run, and the people whose ingenuity created them.
The more I trace the arc of invention, the more I hear
Ecclesiastes: "To every thing there is a season, and a time to every purpose under the Heaven."
The more I know, the more I puzzle over the role of the inventor who invents before that season arrives.
Alexander Bains was such a person. He was born on a Scottish farm in 1810. After
minimal education he apprenticed to a watchmaker, then went to London as a journeyman
Bain read everything he could about the science of his day, especially early work in electricity.
At thirty he built the first electric clock. The timing element was still a pendulum, but instead
driving it with a weight or spring, he used an electromagnet.
He also devised means for using a telegraph system to set a clock in a distant town to the same time
as a local clock. He obtained a series of patents for such systems between 1841 and 52. But he also
made a grave miscalculation.
He showed his early ideas to electrical pioneer Charles Wheatstone. Wheatstone later claimed Bain's
work as his own. History has generally sided with Bain in this conflict, but Wheatstone ruined Bain's
attempts to sell his inventions.
Still (and we're back to our theme) electric clocks and Bain's telegraphic synchronization did not find
general use until the 1920s. When they did, Bain, unlike most who emerge before their time, was still
seen as the primary inventor. And his troubles did not stop with timekeeping.
In 1846, he got British patent protection for a system that recorded telegraph signals on tape. That
way one didn't have to rely on a person to receive a coded message. Bain went to America to sell that
idea and filed for an American patent in April 1848. But Morse received an American patent for such a
system in January.
So Bain put his now-ambiguous patent to work with a Morse competitor. They did well for a while. Then
the powerful Morse legal machine went to work, and cleaned out both Bain and the competitor.
Bain did much more. Perhaps his most interesting ill-timed idea is one he proposed at the same time he
worked on his telegraphic synchronization scheme. It was a system for transmitting images. He
patented an embryonic FAX machine in 1843. Nineteen years later, Italian inventor L'Abbé Caselli actually
demonstrated a system that used Bain's principles. But faxing still didn't catch on.
Bain died poor at 67, in a home for the terminally ill. And we're left asking why things work this way.
In fact, our sense of justice recoils. Yet creating ideas and making money are two separate human enterprises.
Bain managed only the idea part. Yet history might be more just than it first seems. For when we trace
the story of these devices, we find Bain wearing the crown for having changed his world after all. And
that's really no small reward.
I'm John Lienhard, at the University of Houston,
where we're interested in the way inventive minds
See entry for "Bain, Alexander" in the Dictionary of National Biography.
R. W. Burns, Alexander Bain, a most ingenious and meritorious inventor. Engineering
Science and Education Journal, April 1993.
A. Hart-Davis, Eurekaaargh! (London: Michael O'Mara Books Limited, 1999): pp. 107-111.
Note added, Aug. 31, 2015:
Media historian Mark, Schubin writes with some background that I did not have when I wrote this episode in 2005. He points out:
1) Bain actually did not build the first electric clock. That inventor was actually Carl August Steinheil a year earlier, though there's no indication that Bain was influenced by Steinheil's work. Steinheil also came up with the first synchronization and earth battery.
2) Caselli was first to commercialize the fax, but Scientific American reported seeing working image-transmission machines in Bain's New York offices in 1848, and there were published images of Bain image transmissions long before Caselli's fax.
3) Caselli's fax DID catch on, though it wasn't very long lived, probably because it couldn't capture existing images (that hadn't been drawn in insulating ink on a metallic background). Perhaps interestingly, considering your theme, the discoverer of a photoelectric effect, Edmond Becquerel (in 1839), demonstrated an improved version of a Caselli fax but apparently never thought to use his on discovery in it. It wasn't until photoconductivity was discovered in 1872 that attempts at image capture began (in 1877), with the first crude video images following soon thereafter.
The Engines of Our Ingenuity is
Copyright © 1988-2005 by John H.