Engines of Our Ingenuity

No. 1867:
THE WRIGHT BROTHERS' PROPELLERS

by John H. Lienhard

Today, the Wright Brothers' propellers. The University of Houston's College of Engineering presents this series about the machines that make our civilization run, and the people whose ingenuity created them.

This Wednesday, December seventeenth, 2003, marks one century since the Wright Brothers' famous flight. I thought there'd be nothing more to say about it when I found a recent article by three engineers who've studied the propellers of the first Wright Flyer.

Two eight-foot diameter propellers pushed (rather than pulled) the airplane forward. They were made of laminated spruce and a sprocket-driven bicycle chain drove them. Power was supplied by a twelve-horsepower, four-cylinder, homemade engine -- the first internal combustion engine to be made of cast aluminum.

We look at those propellers and hardly see them. Indeed, if we do see them, they strike us as uninteresting. They look like narrow sticks, widening slightly toward their flat tips. And yet, like the rest of the airplane, they represent a huge departure from anything that'd been made before them.

Propellers had only recently been put to use driving ships. But the dynamics of a propeller in water are much different than in air. Water has a thousand times the density of air. In water, one must avoid arranging the flow to give a low pressure anywhere on the blade. That leads to cavitation, which attacks the surface of a ship's propeller.

The Wrights knew they had to get maximum thrust from a very small engine. They settled on a propeller design with an airfoil cross-section. They twisted its blade so the pitch was high near the hub where it moved slowly, and lower out at the tip.

Then they tested a reduced-scale model, measuring the propeller's rpm and thrust. When they were done, they had performance curves. They knew each propeller would provide 67 pounds of thrust at thirty miles an hour -- enough to get the job done.

But they'd also learned enough so they could change the propeller speed to meet different flying conditions. Their primitive engine had no throttle; it operated only at one speed. However, they could change the propeller speed by switching out the sprockets between flights.

Now the authors of this new article reconstruct the Wright propellers from old records, and from fragments of the original propellers. They do wind tunnel tests. The Wrights weren't able to test propellers in their small tunnel. They could only predict how the propellers would act in forward motion.

In the end, computer modeling shows that the Wright's propeller design was almost optimal for their low airspeeds. Old photos of propellers from the not-quite-successful airplanes of people like Samuel P. Langley, Gustave Whitehead, and Hiram Maxim all show the same primitive flaring triangular shape. Those airplane-makers were nowhere close to their contemporaries, the Wright Brothers.

And so, while people try to challenge the Wright Brothers' priority, the vast base of solid engineering continues to tilt in their favor -- detail by detail. Did they invent the airplane? Oh yes indeed. I think we can safely say they really did.

I'm John Lienhard, at the University of Houston, where we're interested in the way inventive minds work.

(Theme music)


R. A. Ash, C. P. Britcher, and K. W. Hyde, Prop-Wrights: How Two Brothers from Dayton Added a New Twist to Airplane Propulsion. Mechanical Engineering (100 Years of Flight Supplement), Dec. 2003, pp. 11-15, 39.


construction of a Wright propeller

From Kaempffert, The New Art of Flying, 1910.



Original Wright propellers
Detail from a 1904 photo, showing original form of Wright propellers (Library of Congress)



Later Wright propellers
A later form of Wright propellers (Kaempffert, 1910)


The Engines of Our Ingenuity is Copyright © 1988-2003 by John H. Lienhard.